In this episode of Talking Markets, Jeff Schulze, Head Investment Strategist at the Franklin Templeton Institute, helps us break down the connections between the latest economic, political and market developments. Our Recession Risk Dashboard continues to flash a strong green signal, reinforced by October’s strong jobs report and a still resilient US consumer. Jeff also covers the recent midterm elections and their market implications, including the historic pattern of strong S&P 500 performance following past midterms. Jeff also explores recent market volatility tied to AI data center buildout concerns, the outlook for fiscal policy and the debt ceiling.
Transcript
Host/John Przygocki: Welcome to Talking Markets with Franklin Templeton. I'm your host, John Przygocki, from the Franklin Templeton Global Marketing Organization. As a forward-thinking asset manager, Franklin Templeton leverages cutting-edge strategies and deep industry insights to unlock opportunities to help grow wealth. We’re your trusted partner for what's ahead. I'm here today in the studio with Jeff Schulze for our monthly update focused on the state of the US economy. Jeff is the Head Investment Strategist at the Franklin Templeton Institute. Jeff, welcome to the show.
Jeff Schulze: Thanks for having me, John.
John Przygocki: Jeff, let's get started by kicking things off with the economy, as we typically do, and then drill down into some other topics like the midterms and recent market volatility. How is the economy holding up through the lens of the Recession Risk Dashboard?
Jeff Schulze: Well, the good news is that the dashboard continues to flash a very strong overall green signal. This is an output that we've had over the course of the summer through the fall. Out of 12 individual indicators, 11 are flashing green (expansion) and only one is flashing red (recession).
So, if there ever was a time to deal with some macro headwinds of higher energy prices and higher long-term interest rates and market volatility, this is the type of dashboard and environment where the economic expansion generally continues.
John Przygocki: So, Jeff, are there any indicators that are jumping out at you?
Jeff Schulze: Yeah, I'm very encouraged by Initial Jobless Claims. This is the number one ranked variable in the dashboard. It has no false positives over the course of the last 50 years. And the four-week moving average, which is how we measure this, is the lowest since 1969. And it suggests that the labor market is on a very sound foundation. And even continuing claims are down double digits from the year earlier. So, we continue to have a low-hire type of environment. But the key is that people are still staying in their jobs and you’re not seeing any stress that layoffs are coming down the pike.
John Przygocki: Speaking about the labor market, we've just gotten the October jobs report. What are your key takeaways there?
Jeff Schulze: The print was strong from top to bottom. Payrolls came in at 165,000 versus 70,000 expected. You saw huge revisions to the prior months of positive 84,000 jobs. Wage growth was firm. The unemployment rate dropped. So, this is a really good development.
And when you look at job creation over the last three months, it's averaged 137,000. That doesn't sound like a lot, but it's well above the break-even level of job creation that's needed to keep the unemployment rate stable. That break-even level has come down a lot because of lower immigration and a lot of baby boomers retiring early. And right now that's about 25 or 30,000. So, it was a really good print overall.
John Przygocki: Does that mean that the Fed is going to hike next month?
Jeff Schulze: I think it does. You had seen December rate hike expectations come down about fears of a slower AI buildout over the course of this week. But after the labor print, you've seen them move back up to about a 76% chance of a rate hike in December. Given what we've seen in the labor markets, I think that we are going to get another hike in December, barring a really negative November jobs release or a severe cooling in inflation, which is not my base case.
John Przygocki: There certainly has been concern about the consumer in the United States with high energy and high interest rates. How is the consumer doing and what do you expect in 2027?
Jeff Schulze: The US consumer has been remarkably resilient. When you look at retail sales—and we like to look at the control group, which excludes volatile components—over the last six months, it's been an annualized trend of 5.2%. Third-quarter consumer spending was 3.8% annualized. A lot of people were expecting the consumer to be struggling in this environment of higher energy and higher long-term interest rates. And the consumer really hasn't batted an eye. And I find that very encouraging.
Now, I do think a lot of the resilience that we've seen is from the high-end consumer, because they tend to spend more when their net worth is moving higher. And household net worth jumped 13 trillion alone in Q2. But I do believe as we turn the page to 2027, the low-end consumer is going to start to join the party in a more aggressive fashion, because they're actually having stronger earnings growth than the middle- and high-end consumer.
And if you get any relief on the energy front, I think that the low-end consumer can start to do better as well. So, the consumer has been resilient.
John Przygocki: Jeff, the US midterm elections have come and gone this week. And the blue wave or the blue tsunami, as many are calling it, has occurred in full force. Are there any things that really took you by surprise in those results?
Jeff Schulze: Blue tsunami. That is a very good way of putting it. I think that is what surprised me the most. I mean, the Democrats are going to have a large majority in the House. Depending on how these uncalled races go, they could have 260 seats there. In the Senate, they have 54 seats. They potentially have the ability to pick up two more. The scale of the tsunami took me by surprise.
But also, it wasn't confined to just the House and the Senate. In key governor races, the Democrats won Texas. They won Ohio. They won Georgia. They won Nevada. I don't think markets were pricing in the magnitude of this sweep, but also the fact that you did see a change of governorships in key states, which is going to potentially affect the data-center buildout that's anticipated over the next couple of years.
John Przygocki: Post election, we have seen a high degree of market volatility here in the past couple of days. Why are the markets so volatile or choppy?
Jeff Schulze: Well, the Democrats won Washington decisively, but Trump still holds the veto. So they're not going to see a lot of federal policy changes unless there's an agreement between the two. But the bigger market impact comes down to the states which hold a large share of the US data center pipeline.
For example, Texas has 27% of US data center projects by gigawatts, and the governor-elect there campaigned on a moratorium on new data center approvals until the legislature sets the rules. So, this was a really important development for that buildout. And if you do see a slowdown in that buildout, a delay, a cancellation of that buildout, it's going to be negative for the companies that are benefiting from that buildout—more specifically, the chip providers, power, cooling in that AI infrastructure build, which has been so critical for the strong market environment that you've seen in the big increase of earnings expectations here in 2026 and into 2027. So, a lot of that volatility is just investors trying to anticipate how much of this new data center construction is going to come offline or potentially be pushed into 2029 or 2030.
John Przygocki: Okay, how about if there is a delay in the AI data center buildout? Is that really a negative?
Jeff Schulze: I don't view it as a negative. I actually think that this is a positive development, because it makes the cycle more sustainable. And what I mean by that is that AI capex may grow more slowly, so the pace is going to change, but the overall scale won't. There's still a huge demand for compute. And if you have a smaller boom on the way up—so, a more measured pace of growth of data centers—you are likely going to have a smaller bust when you eventually get to that point where there's overcapacity and overbuilding a number of years down the line.
When you think about what the impact could be on economic growth, even if you cut AI capex in half next year, which is not my base case, it's going to shave about 40 basis points off of GDP. And if you assume that the equity markets get to a 20% correction, which, again, is not my base case, but if it does, that's going to impact consumer spending by another half a percentage point. Even with that aggressive scenario, you're shaving less than 1% of GDP off of next year. I think this increases the resilience of this economic expansion.
The real issue is the 2028 and 2029 data center projects. But I think when you look at what the Democrats campaigned on, they campaigned on sweetening the deals for local communities. They want the data centers, but they want the local communities to benefit. So, this may increase the cost of production. This may increase the timelines. But ultimately, I think that this will be something that extends the cycle.
John Przygocki: Anthropic recently published an S1 providing investors with insight into the AI ecosystem. What did you walk away with from that read?
Jeff Schulze: The S-1 filing was very highly anticipated by investors, me included, because it provided a cleaner readthrough on the economics of compute, monetization of the application layer and the training. And I came away from it as a glass half full reading.
One thing that we were looking for was the annualized run rate of revenue. It came in at almost 70 billion, which is a little bit less than what we saw the quarter prior. But that is a very strong number, all things considered. So I think that supports the case for returns on the application layer for the hyperscalers and the people who are bringing on compute.
The other thing that I thought was encouraging is that customer concentration is starting to dilute. If you look at the number of $100,000-customers at Anthropic, it literally doubled from June into September, going from 6,000 to almost 12,000. It's not one or two customers that are really driving a lot of that revenue.
And then the last thing is that revenues are growing faster than compute costs, which is a really important development because compute costs are the largest cost item for Anthropic. In 2023, Anthropic spent about $10 on compute to generate each dollar of revenue. It dropped to about two dollars for each dollar of revenue in the first half of last year, and right now it's about $0.55. So, compute has really been that gating factor to profitability. And with economies of scale, I think that this is really bullish for the AI ecosystem.
John Przygocki: Looking beyond or outside of the AI trade, who are the potential winners and losers from a market perspective coming out of the midterms?
Jeff Schulze: Yeah, so we've talked about semiconductors, hyperscalers, neoclouds and data center builders. Those are in front and center of the selloff over the last couple of days. They will continue to probably see a lot of volatility until we can get some visibility on that AI buildout. Texas-exposed names have been part of the selloff here—AI-linked software like Palantir and CrowdStrike. Also, cyclicals and financials have been caught up in the selloff as well along with crypto.
The areas that have been benefiting have been more defensive in nature. Staples, health care, utilities all have been rising. Insurers have been rising. I do think that if you do see SNAP benefits pushed back, that could support the consumer. So, again, consumer staples and consumer discretionary areas that do service that low-income consumer could be beneficiaries as well.
John Przygocki: All right Jeff, coming out of the midterms, what do you think will happen with the US deficit, tariffs and trade policy?
Jeff Schulze: I do think that there's an opportunity for a grand bargain between the Democrats and the White House, because, when you go back to the first Trump administration, when the Democrats won the House in the 2018 midterms, you did have a grand bargain that came together in a bipartisan way, because those parties went on to pass the Bipartisan Budget Act of 2019, which raised both defense and non-defense spending caps and led the Congressional Budget Office to raise its ten-year deficit projection by $1.7 trillion.
So the Democrats would likely want to get Medicaid and SNAP cuts from last year's One Big, Beautiful Bill rolled back or delayed or softened as part of that negotiation. And the Republicans would likely want to have some more defense spending.
When you think about tariffs, that is completely in President Trump's control. You do have a section 301 investigation into excess capacity that's going to come online over the next couple of quarters. When that does, you are going to see that affect a handful of countries and likely increase the tariff rate by a percentage point or two. But I think the key takeaway here is that, even with that backdrop, tariffs are a known quantity. Companies have dealt with them remarkably well. And I don't think that really impacts the economy in a meaningful fashion.
And the same can be said about trade policy as well. That runs through the White House. One way that you could see the Democrats affect trade policy is through the USMCA negotiations with Canada. A lot of states on the border there are suffering because of the tariffs that are going on there. That could be something that makes its way into the negotiations to set up a potential deal with Canada.
John Przygocki: All right, Jeff. How about the debt ceiling? Will that become an issue?
Jeff Schulze: I think it will. You have a lame duck session coming up here over the next month, and I don't see the scope for the Republicans to raise the debt ceiling through reconciliation. There's just not a lot of time. I do think that that gets pushed to 2027, and the Treasury will run into the debt limit issues in Q3 at some time after they exhaust all of the extraordinary measures to keep the government funded.
But we've been at this point before where you've been at the precipice of not increasing the debt ceiling, and every time policymakers find the will to increase the debt ceiling. So I think there will be a lot of brinkmanship. You could have some volatility around that in Q3 of next year. But I do think, just like we've seen time and time again, that there will be a deal that’s struck at the midnight hour.
John Przygocki: Okay, Jeff, transitioning back to capital markets, is there really any reason for optimism for the S&P 500 [Index] regarding the midterm election results?
Jeff Schulze: This is a little bit of a unique year for the S&P 500. Usually the S&P 500 crawls into the midterm elections. Average price return since 1950 has been about 1.3%. Up until the midterms year-to-date, the S&P 500 was up almost 11%. So, we're seeing some volatility post midterms.
But for the S&P 500, the most important thing historically has been just getting through the midterms. Because when you go back to 1950, in the 12 months after the midterm elections, the S&P 500 has gained an average of 15.1%. And out of those 19 observations, every single one of them produced a positive price return. So, with the economy still on a solid foundation, with earnings still historically strong, even if those earnings come down a little bit because of the data center buildout being pushed further into 2028 and 2029, I think that this seasonal tailwind is going to continue to be positive for the S&P 500.
John Przygocki: Are there any other reasons why markets have been so choppy, so volatile? Is it maybe a connection to peak earnings?
Jeff Schulze: Peak earnings has certainly been a reason why we've had some volatility pre-election for the last couple of months. Usually when you get to peak earnings growth, you're transitioning from early- to mid-cycle. So, a lot of the early-cycle winners start to see some pain. And a lot of times investors rotate into higher-quality names. And that's exactly what you've seen.
But not all earnings peaks are equal. Since 1980, if you've had really strong earnings growth after that peak, that has given you a very different market experience. So, again, going back 45 years to 1980, if your earnings growth following the peak was above 10%, strong earnings growth, forward 12-month returns for the S&P 500 has been 19.6%. If you've been below that 10% earnings growth threshold (so, kind of a weak earnings environment), 12-month returns have been 6.1%. And right now consensus expects almost double that 10% bogey for the S&P 500. And even if, again, some of these earnings expectations come down because of this data center moratorium issue, we're still clearly above that 10% threshold with earnings.
John Przygocki: Jeff, as we look to conclude this afternoon's conversation, do you have a closing thought for our listeners?
Jeff Schulze: Well, when you look at the selloff that we've had here, what we've been really looking for for the end of this selloff was the index to start to move down in a more material fashion. You've seen a lot of carnage underneath the surface. The index has been relatively resilient, and you're starting to see the index pullback. And I think this is starting to set the stage for the final capitulation, if you will, where the markets can start to move higher on a more durable basis.
But I think more importantly, John, one of the things that we've been talking about at the Institute for a number of years is this broadening of market participation. We're seeing it in spades. If you look back to October, the equally-weighted S&P 500 outperformed the cap-weighted version by 5%, which was the widest spread in a month since April of 2009. When you look at the Russell 1000 Value: outperformed the Russell 1000 Growth by 10%, the widest spread since 2001. 76% of the estimated 500 stocks beat the index, the best breadth since 1986. So we've been advocating to stay diversified.
John Przygocki: Jeff, thank you for sharing your insight with us all today. To all of our listeners, thank you for spending your valuable time with us for today's update. If you'd like to hear more Talking Markets with Franklin Templeton, please visit our archive of previous episodes and subscribe on Apple Podcasts, Amazon and Spotify.
This material reflects the analysis and opinions of the speakers as of November 6, 2026, and may differ from the opinions of portfolio managers, investment teams or platforms at Franklin Templeton. It is intended to be of general interest only and should not be construed as individual investment advice or a recommendation or solicitation to buy, sell or hold any security or to adopt any investment strategy. It does not constitute legal or tax advice.
The views expressed are those of the speakers and the comments, opinions and analyses are rendered as of the date of this podcast and may change without notice. The information provided in this material is not intended as a complete analysis of every material fact regarding any country, region, market, industry, security or strategy. Statements of fact are from sources considered reliable, but no representation or warranty is made as to their completeness or accuracy.

